Ruger AR-556 M4-Style Direct Impingment MSR 223/5.56 8502. vs. Palmetto State Armory PA-15 223/5.56 46637. And that couple that is or was arrested in St Louis by the democratic state attorney for defending their house/ Sorry, but my soapbox is pretty shaky now, gotta go. The SR556 (and other piston ARs) were a solution in search of a problem. The extractor is destroying the casing when it fires so it has nothing to grab on to in order to extract. Period. It feels like a $1200 rifle but costs alot less. Dealer had no trouple taking the Ruger apart. Neither pistol grip was better than the other. None at all- The gun sighted in quickly and was super accurate. I don't like a carbine length gas system on a 16" barrel and the Ruger has that, not sure about the Springfield. Step up to the next level of Saint models and youll see a nicely designed free-float tube. Welcome to the forum, shame your first post has to be a problem with the Saint. You do not pay I was wrong! When you find a different stock you prefer, swap it out. The confidence you gain in yourself, your rifle, and your ability to handle a situation is more than worth the price of admission. If not by you, by someone a friend, a family member, a vet, or if you have to, just pay a gunsmith. Here is what I did: I loaded-up three 30-round magazines for each gun, and one at a time, I emptied those mags as fast as I could pull the trigger just making sure the guns had no malfunctions. Keep in mind that when were talking about AR-15s were talking about piecesparts more than we are a whole package. I thought about breaking into some of my personal stash of AR ammo, and running more varieties of ammo through both guns, but I didnt want to get into my own ammo supply at this point in time dont know if Id ever be able to replace the ammo, or when. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Jim is the originator of the American Redoubt movement and a frequent talk show and podcast guest. Took it to the range Sunday. Unfortunately I am a reloader and the components ( bullets, primers and powder) are very hard to come by now. The barrel has a right hand twist of 1:8. Another bonus, another one less thang to purchase. Theres nothing this gun needs. Both guns will last a lifetime, too. I am a vet, but the last long gun I fired with any regularity, was my M16A2 in 1990. Simple light and handie. I recently purchased a few 20 rd boxes of .223 and a box of .44 Mag at Midwayusa. I have always thought of Stag's as being solid mid level guns, nothing fancy but good quality. If you're talking about past politics then Ruger isn't any better than SA. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Absolutely no way I would trust my life to this weapon. The problem was me. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. It will bring up his Glock reviews. Armalite: M-15 A4. Extremely disappointing. How do define a good AR15? Copyright @2023 TigerDroppings.com. Not sure if its the ammo or the pistol (firing pin, spring, etc) but never have that happen with better quality brass rounds. Our mail forwarding address is: James Wesley, Rawles Plus Ruger's customer service is top notch. The trigger pull on the Springfield is much lighter and crisp as well, but very smooth thanks to the coating Springfield applies to the trigger group. And yes, i would be totally comfortable putting into a combat scenario. The Wall Street Journal had an article in the Opinion page, just 21,500 votes judicially located in 3 states would have given Trump a second term. Waiting for them to fix. Definitely made in the u.s can speak in 100% assurance, Dont waste your money on a Saint Now on my soapbox, what happened at the capitol was wrong and has given the democratic commies more ammo to go after everyone else. The Saint Edge models start at $1,300. Compare. That's what General Custer's troops said after their defeat at Little Big Horn because they were armed wirh trapdoor Springfield rifles and colt .45's and they were finished with Springfield. You can now buy the. The district attorney in Multnomah Oregon the Portland area has told the police there to not arrest people for simple crimes like disorderly conduct, because he will not prosecute those people. Since I bought mine, Springfield has turned the original Saint into its own line. While the Saint is chambered for the 5.56mm round, it will also accept .223 Remington (like all other 5.56mm rifles). While many people (myself included) were skeptical of Springfields first AR-15, the Saint has proven itself to be a stand-out among entry-level AR-15s. Both Ruger. This gun has the bones to support whatever you want to turn it into. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. But no one remembers that. It shoots fine, but I would caution anyone buying a Saint that thinks they might ever want to swap parts with a regular Milspec AR-15. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. For those who care less about the numbers and more about the overall review, Ill sum up the key points you should know before possibly purchasing a Saint. Second round, exactly the same thing. Their prices are not the lowest but they are more than fair for the market. However, my biases might have come through in this piece, and I liked one a little bit more than the other but no matter what it is a personal preference, and you have to make up your own mind as to which gun is better for you. For example, a regular length charging handle will not fit in my Saint. In addition to shooting it myself, I have also had quite a few friends and first-time shooters experience the ease and enjoyment of the Saint. trigger is smoooooth imo . Lexi Olson is currently a full-time college student, range worker, and gun nerd. What is new about it, though, is that they got it right. Compare specifications of Ruger AR-556 300 Blackout 8572 and Springfield Saint Victor Pistol 300 Blackout STV909300B. Furniture on the Saint is from Bravo Company, another good choice (very popular and highly recommended in the aftermarket). And, to be sure, both of these ARs are the basic entry-level ARs being offered by these two fine companies. I believe that, if I mounted some kind of magnifying optics on both rifles, I could have easily gotten groups down to about of an inch or less, without too much trouble. Springfield has also released eight SAINT variants over the preceding years; almost all of these, fortunately, features a. While its not quite Pelican level, it is certainly better than a cheap Plano, and definitely better than getting a gun in a cardboard box. 3 9 9 comments Best Add a Comment Have you used the Springfield Saint? During my research, these are the other entry level AR-15s I considered. We'll take a closer look and help you make the right choice! When I bought the gun I also purchased two extra PMAG-30 and a PMAG-40. The first time I shot my new AR Saint the retaining pins for the trigger group backed out. This was my first personal ar-15. Im just glad we now have AR comparison articles and have sometimez heated debates. Hours of review videos later, I found myself with a lengthy internet history and some positive assurance about the Saint. With ammo prices, the .22 pistol and ammo will be paid for in the savings by not spending $400 to get 400 rounds of .40 training rounds. Learn the 3 most popular shooting stances & more. Mar 15, 2017. woodtown said: Got my saint 3/1 had several failures to eject. Would instead recommend OP buy a complete upper and lower from Aero Precision and slap 'em together. The two that are strongest contenders in my research are the 16" Ruger MPR with B5 furniture (Model 8542), or the 16" Saint Victor (STV916556B). $490 for a complete rifle kit, all you have to do is buy a stripped lower and Del-Ton sells those for $125.00. Adjustable gas blocks allow. sorry everyone, Im just another grey haired , mid 70s old fart waiting to be put into a reeducation camp and or work camp to do meaningful work at a minimum wage, according to Bernie Sanders supporters. So mags loaded and gun cleaned I took it to the range this morning. And I just saw Nancy Pelosi on a rerun of 60 minutes . I know there is better out there but as far as getting the most bang for my buck I have it down to these two options. Ill let go of a little if I think a person has little or none, but in the present environment I really dont want to sell. This is one of my favorite aspects of the Saint. Daniel Defense . I bought a StagArms and Im really happy with it. If I knew then what I know now, I probably would have built my own. Both seem like solid platforms. Brand: Springfield. Lots of guns are being sold as every time I went to a local store several customers were filling out the 4473 forms. Feels good. However, I took off both rear sights on the guns, and replaced them with a detachable carry hand rear sight. Bravo Company furniture all around. Any help is appreciated. All that said, I switched to the G21 and will remain with a round that delivers a big hydrostatic shock. She can load her own mags but apparently being her gun boy is why she married me. Fixed it means all the issues we (and me very loudly) have identified have been incorporated by Springfield Armory. Build your own. Havent used the Saint yet but Ive been drooling over it ever since I saw it. Needed a cleaning rod to clear the spent casing. When the Saint hit the stores I could not wait to get my hands on I own some Springfield firearms and was excited but because they had not put out such a firearm I decided to wait for a year and see the reviews and until today 2018 February 14th I heard it's still a piece of junk I live here in Nevada where you can shoot before you buy and found it few of the stores do not even allow you to shoot the saint and when I finally did it did exactly what everyone said it jammed every 15 rounds I always see these massive reviews about junk Glocks the junk vp9 and now the junk saint I believe that the people riding these reviews are either being paid by the big companies or have never actually done any real hands on reviews of the Firearms they're talking about going out to the range and shoot in your 10-round magazine does not make it an excellent or superb or reliable firearm so once again do yourself a favor drop a Sig and let me know how it goes. I liked the pistol grip on the Springfield a lot of course, nothing wrong with the pistol grip on the Ruger, either I just preferred the Springfield pistol grip a little bit more. Type in ( Glock Cascio) and hit enter. James Wesley, Rawles (JWR) is Founder and Senior Editor of SurvivalBlog, the original prepping /survival blog for when the Schumer Hits The Fan (SHTF). http://palmettostatearmory.com/psa-1516447166.html, https://survivorsystems.com/productsnt-stock-black, https://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/35446/redirect. Saint vs M&P15 vs AR-556 | Best AR-15 Pistol Comparison & Review Watch on A quick review of three popular AR-15 Pistols Springfield Saint Pistol Smith & Wesson M&P15 Pistol Ruger AR556 Pistol Compared and Reviewed Note to readers: Please click the share buttons above or below. If I could find nothing but Tulammo or Wolf I would not feel totally unarmed. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. you a link to reset your password. I didnt expect any and didnt have any problems and the barrels on both guns were very hot after 90 rounds down range. The problem is almost akin to the problem the characters in the movie The Road and another movie The Survivalist ammunition scarcity. Personalize your experience. Cheers BMW DOG. My son asked me to get an AR so we could shoot on weekends, and that started my choice to get back in the game. Yet, fellow gunners at the range seem to look down on it. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Ruger. It ships with a Magpul brand magazine. Tucson gun stores are still getting ARs and AK types and the prices are still somewhat reasonable. could be a tad more accurate. iron sights good qual and co witness. One gun store owner in my area said primers are BO from his supplier for 10-12 months right now. Keep in mind, $739 is a recommended retail price from the manufacturers. It was tough to part with that much money for a weapon until the first trigger pull. Item Number: ST916556BLC-B5. I must admit that I hardly shoot mine anymore. Its just hard to go wrong with a basic, no-frills AR, like the Springfield or the Ruger. The Saint Edge ticked the boxes. Look to http://www.gunbroker.com or http://www.armslist.com for expensive but available ammunition. bought mine about 6 months ago and put several hundreds rounds thru it and frankly think this is a smokin' deal, in OD Green looks like love at first sight. I have built a few since but it was the first AR I got. The Saint seriesevery variation in the lineuphas engineering ideas and specific parts incorporated to ramp up these guns to what "we," custom builders, have been incorporating for years now. The twist rate of both rifles is also different. A good article, especially for the people who arent into the ar shooting platform but are looking to get into one ( or two ). In the end, a person will usually like one firearm over another, and probably for no solid reason just a personal bias. I dropped an ACOG on mine, and it's been a great shooter for years never one failure out of thousands of rounds and even cheap steel. But in the ever-evolving world of the AR-15, prices are dropping while quality is skyrocketing for Americas favorite sporting rifle. Daniel Defense. Good article and anyone would be well served to own either one of these weapons. Springfield Armorys choice of trigger fits perfectly into this whole package as Im warranting ityou really dont have to run out and buy a Geissele before you can shoot it. I love it too! The free-float tube makes a noticeable difference in on-target accuracy. Capacity: 30+1-Round Cartridge: 5.56 mm NATO Front Sight: None Length: 32.25-35.8 Magazine Included: 1 x 30-Round Magazine Type: Removable Muzzle: Flash Suppressor Rear Sight: None Stock Material: Polymer Weight: 6.28 lbs Made in the USA Features It is accurate to 300 yards (longest range I have available) with a Hi-Lux MM2 red dot. It really comes down to how much you want to spend when youre buying a weapon. In the same way, the Saint is an AR-15 made by Springfield Armory. The stock is BCM Gunfighter Mod O, and the trigger guard and grip also are from Bravo Company. Just to give you a quick idea, the Ruger is at about $799, and MSRP is about $739. But honestly, Id go with a PSA before both of them. I personally dont like doing any sort of Versus firearms articles, because it is difficult, if not impossible, to remain totally unbiased. JP It is accurate,reliable and light. 150 plus days of rioting in Portland Or, businesses being damaged and burned down in Minn, New York, L.A and other large cities. Both are very accurate and trouble-free. Ruger has a ring that tists tight to hold the foregrip whereas the M&P has the traditional one. This lightweight, polymer sight is windage-adjustable; folds flat to make room for optics and is spring-loaded to allow for rapid deployment with . I also added a BCM Vertical Foregrip, because why not. Handguns; Rifles; Shotguns; Parts; . So I walked into the store selling the M&P five minutes after the last one sold. Daniel Defense DDM4V11 5. Caliber 5.56x45mm NATO (.223 REM) Color Black Barrel 16" LW Profile CMV, Melonite, 1:8 Sights Low Profile Spring-Loaded Adjustable Flip-Up Upper Receiver Forged 7075 T6 Aluminum, Type III Hardcoat Anodized, Forward Assist, M4 Feed Ramps Lower Receiver I've seen ARs with standard handguards shoot 1 MOA with hand loads, and that's 10 shot groups, not the bullsh*t 3 shot group internet commandos love to go by. It's a very accurate rifle, has run 100% and is a great way to ease into the addiction. Box 303 The furniture, as already mentioned is completely different on these guns. They both have different furniture though, and that means something to many people we have our preferences, of course. at STILL a Already looking to purchase my first AR-15, I did what any gun lover on a budget would do: Hours of review videos later, I found myself with a lengthy internet history and some positive assurance about the Saint. Doing my own calculations, Springfield sure doesnt seem to be artificially running up the price to offer the higher-cost features (like some factory custom shops seem to do). Have to admit, it I had the funds, I would love to try the Saint. My other conspirators assisting found the Sig tread to be somewhat proprietary while the M&P-15 styling to be somewhat flat. Hand-Picked Daily GUN DEALS, and Exclusive Coupons Codes >>>. Glock lists five different pistols in .40: the G22, G 23, G 24, G27, G35. Get proficient on YOUR time. So, to which Springfield modern sporting rifle are you referring? I try not to get political in my articles if I can avoid itbut in this case, you, our valued readers, had better heed my advice, and if you want an AR, get one now if you can find one. I put on a different handguard, BUIS, and trigger in it. No there isn't; people overplay free floating way too much. Anyone know for sure? Nice rifle. Diamondback DB-15 vs. Springfield Saint Victor (AR pistol versions) Centerfire Rifles - Semiautomatic or Gas Operated I'd like to give my first impressions. Short-barreled rifle (SBR) and pistol Saint variants are also available, as is the premier Saint Edge with top-shelf components and features. Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting. You'll pay a bit more for the .30-caliber - around $50 more - with the new pistol's MSRP $949. Springfield also fitted an F height front . Sig Sauer SIGM400 Tread ***** The AR 15 is one of the world's most well known and popular rifles. That being said, the Saint B5 was comfortable and easy to shoot. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval. Thanks for your service bro bless you and keep on bearing. What is new about it, though, is that they got it right. Moyie Springs, Idaho 83845. I wouldn't limit myself to just those two. Dont talk to me about price when your life may be on the line. Sgt. The Ruger has a skinny, polymer handguard, and standard M4 telescoping stock. People that say this gun is junk crack me up !! The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt! Ive probably put about 100 rounds through it. I'm sure that it's good, but it is also new; I'd pick the Ruger simply because it has been out for a while and proven. There is no complete trust in even US made ammo but that is who I trust the most. Savage Arms is another major gun manufacturer that didn't have an AR rifle in its product line until recently. But I wouldn't have know what I know now if I hadn't purchased the SW in the first place. I would go with the Ruger. Weve built dozens of ARs and well cover all the best AR-15 upgrades such as handguards, triggers, BCGs, gas blocks, and more. Springfield knows when to invent their own wheel, and when theres just no reason to reinvent a perfectly functioning wheel available from worthwhile others. #1 Trusted Gravity Water Purification System! Controls are similar, such as the bolt catch and the selector. There is a prayer or saying out there that goes something like this.